The resignation of Aga Syed Ruhullah Mehdi from the National Conference and his decision to relinquish his Lok Sabha seat marks a significant rupture in Jammu and Kashmir’s political landscape. But beneath the theatrics of Tuesday’s Budgam rally lies a more troubling question, what does principled politics actually look like in a region where every gesture is weighed against its electoral utility?
Ruhullah’s speech, timed to coincide with his father’s anniversary, was heavy with symbolism. He invoked dignity, accused Chief Minister Omar Abdullah of sacrificing principles for power, and called for a new movement that transcends regional and religious divides. Yet the National Conference’s response cut to the bone, where was this conscience when Ruhullah served as a minister in 2010? Where was it during his 2014 election campaign on an NC ticket? Why did he wait until now?
These are uncomfortable questions, and the NC was right to ask them. Politics in Kashmir has long been plagued by convenient conversions, leaders who discover their principles only when electoral arithmetic shifts. Ruhullah’s claim that he “got freedom” from his party may be sincere, but sincerity alone does not answer why that freedom arrived so late.
Into this vacuum steps the BJP’s Ram Madhav, suggesting Ruhullah held his rally with “the blessings of our people.” The implication is unmistakable: what looks like a rebellion might be something else entirely. Ruhullah has denied any alignment with the BJP, but in Kashmir’s political theatre, perception often matters more than denial.
The truth is that neither Ruhullah’s theatrical resignation nor the NC’s wounded indignation addresses the fundamental crisis facing Jammu and Kashmir. Issues remain rampant. What Ruhullah has done is expose the fault lines within the National Conference, a party that has governed for decades but increasingly appears uncertain about what it stands for beyond its own survival.
For the people of Kashmir, the real question is not whether Ruhullah was sincere or the NC was betrayed. It is whether any of this will translate into better schools, more jobs, and a politics that treats citizens as more than vote banks. On that count, Tuesday’s drama offers little comfort. The resignation will be accepted. A by-election may follow. But until Kashmir’s political class moves beyond the cycle of grievance and gesture, the region’s deepest wounds will remain unaddressed, and its people will continue to wait for leaders who offer more than speeches.

